| Dokumendiregister | Kultuuriministeerium |
| Viit | 1-12/1234-1 |
| Registreeritud | 16.11.2026 |
| Sünkroonitud | 17.11.2026 |
| Liik | Sissetulev kiri |
| Funktsioon | 1 Ministeeriumi ja valitsemisala tegevuse planeerimine ja juhtimine |
| Sari | 1-12 Kirjavahetus õigusalastes küsimustes (sh ministeeriumile kooskõlastamiseks saadetud õigusaktide/dokumentide eelnõud) |
| Toimik | 1-12/2026 Kirjavahetus õigusalastes küsimustes (sh ministeeriumile kooskõlastamiseks saadetud õigusaktide/dokumentide eelnõud) |
| Juurdepääsupiirang | Avalik |
| Adressaat | AIPPI Eesti Rahvuslik Töörühm |
| Saabumis/saatmisviis | AIPPI Eesti Rahvuslik Töörühm |
| Vastutaja | Bianka Soe (KULTUURIMINISTEERIUM, Loomingu osakond) |
| Originaal | Ava uues aknas |
| Taotle dokumendi eemaldamist või parandamist |
ASSOCIATION INTERNATIONALE POUR LA PROTECTION DE LA PROPRIETE INTELLECTUELLE
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR THE PROTECTION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
A I P P I EESTI
Lp kultuuriminister Pr Heidy Purga Kultuuriministeerium Suur-Karja 23 15076 Tallinn
9. november 2026. a. AIPPI soovitused intellektuaalomandi õiguskaitse valdkonnas
Austatud kultuuriminister pr Heidy Purga Intellektuaalomandi Kaitse Rahvusvaheline Assotsiatsioon (International Association for the Protection of Intellectual Property, lühidalt AIPPI) on rahvusvaheline organisatsioon, mis on pühendunud intellektuaalomandi õiguskaitse arendamisele ja parendamisele, uurides olemasolevaid siseriiklikke seadusi ning tehes ettepanekuid nende seaduste ühtlustamiseks rahvusvaheliselt tasandil. AIPPI-l on umbes 8000 liiget üle maailma enam kui 110 riigist, sh Eestist. AIPPI Eesti Rahvuslik Töörühm on tegev alates 1992. aastast. Iga-aastaselt korraldab AIPPI maailmakongressi, millel on tavaliselt umbes 2000 osavõtjat. AIPPI 2026 maailmakongress toimus 07-10. oktoobril Saksamaal, Hamburgis, mille käigus võeti vastu viis resolutsiooni erinevatel intellektuaalomandit puudutavatel teemadel, sh tööstusomandiõiguse valdkonnas. AIPPI peasekretariaadi ülesandel edastame käesolevaga AIPPI resolutsioonid järgnevatel teemadel:
Divisional applications and double patenting (Eraldatud patenditaotlused ja topeltpatentimine)
Parody as a defense to trade mark infringement (Paroodia kui kaitse kaubamärgiõiguse rikkumise korral)
Online infringement and territoriality considerations (Veebipõhised rikkumised ja territoriaalsuse küsimused)
Dynamic blocking injunctions (Dünaamilised blokeerimiskorraldused) SC Resolution on Microbiome-Based Inventions (Ülemkohtu otsus mikrobioomipõhiste
leiutiste kohta)
Osundatud resolutsioonide alusmaterjalid (Study Guidelines, Summary reports and Group Reports) on täiendavaks tutvumiseks kättesaadavad AIPPI veebilehel aadressil https://aippi.soutron.net/Portal/Default/en-GB/SearchResults
2
Lisad: Vastu võetud resolutsioonid. Lugupidamisega (allkirjastatud digitaalselt) (allkirjastatud digitaalselt) Urmas Kauler Cady Kaisa Rivera AIPPI Eesti Rahvusliku Töörühma juhataja sekretär Cc: Peaminister Justiits- ja digiminister Majandus- ja tööstusminister Patendiameti peadirektor
Q299-RES-C-2026
1
2026 AIPPI World Congress – Hamburg Adopted Resolution 10 October 2026
Resolution
2026 – Study Question - Copyright
Online infringement and territoriality considerations
Background: 1) This Resolution concerns the application of the principle of territoriality to copyright in the digital era and, in particular, it aims to identify the criteria for the determination of the competent jurisdiction and applicable law in case of online copyright infringement. 2) The following definitions are not subject to harmonisation proposal but meant to clarify the meaning of the terms used in this Resolution:
• The term “Private International Law” means national/regional provisions, their interpretation, as well as treaties (e.g. Berne Convention), that are applicable, in a specific jurisdiction/country, in order to determine the competent jurisdiction and the applicable law.
• The term "Domicile' means: for a natural person, the place of his/her habitual
residence/permanent home. for a legal person, the place where it has its statutory seat, central
administration, or principal place of business. • The term “Place of Infringement” means the place of the events which gave
rise to or are the origin of the copyright infringement. • The term “Place of Damage” means the place where the damage occurred,
i.e. the place where the infringing act produced its effects, e.g. places of communication of works, meaning communication to users.
Q299-RES-C-2026
2
• The term “Accessibility” means one of the two theories used to determine the Place of Damage, referring to whether the public in the relevant country or region can access the website or app (application software).
• The term “Targeting” or “Targeted Country” means one of the two theories used to determine the Place of Damage, referring to whether the website or app is directed or targeted at the public in the relevant country or region.
• The term “Website Operator” means a natural or legal person who is responsible for the content and presentation of a website, app., etc., including deciding what is published and how it is accessed by the public.
• The term “Website Hosting Provider” means a service provider that supplies the infrastructure and technical resources required to run and display a website on the internet, such as server space or connectivity.
• The term “Domain Name Hosting Provider” means a service provider that registers, manages, and maintains domain names, on behalf of its holder. It does not include domain name regulatory institutions, such as ICANN, JPNIC, etc.
• The term “Geoblocking” means a technical measure that restricts or prevents access to online specific contents by users located in a particular country or region, typically by reference to the user’s IP address or other location-identifying data.
3) 36 reports were received from AIPPI’s National and Regional Groups and Independent Members providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (which can be found at www.aippi.org). 4) At the AIPPI World Congress in Hamburg in 2026, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI. AIPPI resolves that:
1) Harmonisation of Private International Law, and the use and legal effects of geoblocking, in the context of online copyright infringement is desirable, due to the cross-border nature of the internet.
Competent court / Conflict-of-jurisdiction
Q299-RES-C-2026
3
2) Jurisdiction for online copyright infringement should be established where
there is a connecting factor. Following connecting factors should be applicable:
o the Defendant’s Domicile o the Place of Infringement o the Place of Damage.
3) The Defendant's Domicile should be a connecting factor to determine the
competent court in cases of online copyright infringement. • For the purposes of identifying Defendant’s Domicile, Domicile of the
Website Operator and the Domicile of the Website Hosting Provider, in each case to the extent they can be considered as a copyright infringer, should generally be considered relevant.
• The Domicile of the Domain Name Hosting Provider should not be a relevant factor unless the Domain Name Hosting Provider can itself be considered complicit in the infringement.
• For the purposes of identifying the Defendant’s Domicile in disputes involving multiple infringers (e.g., a Website Operator and a Website Hosting Provider and/or Domain Name Hosting Provider, to the extent they can be considered as infringers upon the circumstances of the case), the Domicile of any of such infringer should be considered relevant, provided the claims presented to the court are so closely connected that it is expedient to hear and determine them together to avoid rights holders from being forced to bring proceedings in multiple countries and the risk of irreconcilable judgments resulting from separate proceedings.
• Where jurisdiction is based on the Defendant’s Domicile, the competent court should be entitled to hear and decide the full dispute in any country or jurisdiction worldwide, including multi-territorial claims, each act of infringement being subject to the applicable substantive law(s) of the territory(ies) for which the protection is claimed.
4) The Place of Infringement should be a connecting factor to determine the competent court in cases of online copyright infringement.
• For the purposes of identifying the Place of Infringement, the place of infringing acts should be relevant, e.g. the place from where the infringing content was uploaded and/or made available online or where an AI system/model is trained, depending on the applicable law.
Q299-RES-C-2026
4
• Where jurisdiction is based on the Place of Infringement, the competent
court should be entitled to hear and decide the full dispute in any country or jurisdiction worldwide, including multi-territorial claims, each act of infringement being subject to the applicable substantive law(s) of the territory(ies) for which the protection is claimed.
5) The Place of Damage should be a connecting factor to determine the competent court in cases of online copyright infringement.
• For the purposes of identifying the Place of Damage, the Accessibility to the work should serve as the starting point for closer examination of the Place of Damage, but it should not be a sole decisive criterion. Whether the jurisdiction has been targeted by the relevant Website Operator should also be considered. The relevant criteria for assessing the jurisdiction of the Targeted Country should include:
the language of the website; the currency of payment; market orientation; public targeted by promotional activities; and/or the existence of business facilities or operation in the country.
Other factors may be considered as indicating targeting of a specific market.
• Where jurisdiction is based on the Place of Damage, the competent court should be entitled to hear and decide the claims relating to the damages, and prejudices occurring within the territory of the national court.
Applicable law / Conflicts-of-laws rules 6) The law of the country for which territory protection is claimed (lex loci protectionis), as enshrined in Article 5(2) of the Berne Convention, should be the central criterion to determine the law applicable to the issue of online copyright infringement. 7) The expression “the law of the place for which territory protection is claimed” should be interpreted, in view of the claims presented by the plaintiff, the territorial scope of national copyright laws, and the characteristics of the infringement, as follows:
• to refer to the Law of the Place of Damage, i.e. the law of the Targeted country; or
Q299-RES-C-2026
5
• to refer also to the Law of the Place of Infringement (in particular the place of uploading the infringing content).
8) In cases of online copyright infringement involving multiple jurisdictions, the parties may agree on the law to be applied to all or part of the dispute, to the extent permitted by the applicable rules of Private International Law. Geoblocking 9) Geoblocking should be considered an appropriate and proportionate means of preserving the territoriality of copyright in the digital environment. 10) Geoblocking measures should be a substantial part of the overall assessment made by the courts of measures that could be adopted by operators (e.g. Website Operators) in order to achieve the goal to prevent online copyright infringement in countries to which they are not allowed to make available such materials (either by contract or by law). 11) Geoblocking might not always be sufficiently technically effective in preventing access to online copyright material. Therefore, to raise such effectiveness to prevent or discourage access to content in a blocked country, Geoblocking should to the extent technically and reasonably feasible and proportionate in the circumstances, be supported with proportional complementary measures, such as contractual and informational safeguards (territorial terms of use, alert-and- confirm screens, redirection), and international cooperation on notice-and- takedown and on the recognition of blocking orders across jurisdictions.
Q300-RES-G-2026
1
2026 AIPPI World Congress – Hamburg Adopted Resolution 10 October 2026
Resolution
2026 – Study Question – General
Dynamic Blocking Injunctions
Background:
1) This Resolution concerns the recognition of Dynamic Blocking Injunctions as a remedy to tackle online intellectual property (IP) infringement, their scope and availability, the principles governing their grant, implementation, duration and review, and the need to balance effective IP enforcement with other legitimate rights and interests. 2) For the purposes of this Resolution, “Dynamic Blocking Injunction” (DBI) refers to an injunctive order designed to address online IP infringement by enabling it to extend, without the need to commence fresh proceedings, to subsequently identified online locations, access points or content falling within the scope of the original order. 3) The digital age has led to a proliferation of large-scale online IP infringement in the form of, for example, “hydra-headed” mirror websites, proxies, live-stream piracy, cyber-lockers and other online locations that can rapidly clone, redirect or relocate their operations. There is a broad consensus that conventional or “static” injunctions - which are limited to a set of identified defendants or online locations and require right holders to repeatedly approach courts for new orders - may be insufficient to effectively address rapidly evolving and adaptive forms of online IP infringement. 4) Over the past decade, DBI has been recognised or granted in a number of jurisdictions, particularly in the context of copyright piracy and unauthorised live
Q300-RES-G-2026
2
streaming, and increasingly in relation to other forms of online IP infringement. Depending on the applicable legal framework, such injunctions may be directed against infringers, against intermediaries whose services are used in connection with the infringement without requiring any finding of liability on their part for the underlying infringement, or against both. International and regional initiatives have also highlighted their potential role as an effective enforcement mechanism, subject to appropriate safeguards against disproportionate over-blocking and interference with legitimate interests. 5) Cross-jurisdictional (i) recognition (ii) implementation and (iii) enforcement of DBI is not addressed by this Resolution. Issues concerning costs and damages are also outside the scope of this Resolution. 6) 36 Reports were received from AIPPI’s National and Regional Groups and Independent Members providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (which can be found at www.aippi.org). 7) At the AIPPI World Congress in Hamburg in 2026, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI. AIPPI Resolves that: Recognition 1) It is desirable to have global recognition of DBI to ensure effective enforcement against certain online IP infringement. 2) National and regional legal frameworks should provide clear rules and/or principles governing DBI, including their grant or refusal, modification or revocation, appeal, implementation, including a requirement for expeditious procedures, as well as appropriate safeguards to ensure a proper balance between IP rights, freedom of expression and other public interest considerations.
Q300-RES-G-2026
3
Scope and Applicability 3) DBI should be available to enforce at least:
• Copyright and neighbouring/related rights; • Trademarks; • Designs; • Geographical indications.
Typical examples of infringing conduct for which DBI could be granted include audiovisual, music and literary piracy, unauthorised live streaming of time- sensitive events, online counterfeiting, illegal online marketplaces, AI-generated content and deepfakes. 4) National and regional legal frameworks may decide whether DBI should be available in cases involving patent infringement, taking into account the complex technical or legal assessments that may be required in such cases and/or may make DBI inappropriate in certain circumstances. 5) National and regional legal frameworks may decide whether DBI should be available in cases involving the unlawful acquisition, use or disclosure of trade secrets, taking into account the issues of confidentiality and complex legal assessments that may be required in such cases and/or may make DBI inappropriate in certain circumstances. 6) While issuing DBI, care should be exercised to avoid the disproportionate over- blocking of lawful content or activities, unintended chilling effects and/or disproportionate interference with (i) legitimate business activities, (ii) freedom of expression or (iii) access to information. Practice and Procedure 7) The authority to grant DBI should reside with courts and/or other appropriate institutions competent to issue injunctions. The implementation thereof can be delegated to other authorities, as permissible under national or regional legal frameworks.
Q300-RES-G-2026
4
8) National and regional legal frameworks may determine the factors to be taken into account when deciding whether to grant or refuse a DBI. Such factors may include, where relevant:
• Proof of a clear prima facie case of IP infringement; • The nature, extent and urgency of the actual or potential harm; • The proportionality and necessity for the grant of the DBI; • The flagrancy of infringing conduct; • Whether the primary purpose of the relevant website or online service is to
facilitate or commit IP infringement; • The operator’s deliberate falsification or concealment of its true identity, or
use of anonymity; • Silence, refusal to comply or inaction following receipt of formal legal
notices; • Reappearance or mirror-cloning across alternative domains or IP addresses
following prior enforcement actions; or • Compliance with any applicable requirements of due process.
9) The scope of a DBI should be proportionate to the nature and extent of the infringing activity. Blocking measures should be appropriately targeted and/or applied to avoid disproportionate interference with lawful content, freedom of expression or legitimate commercial activities. 10) A DBI may be directed against any relevant intermediary, including Internet Service Providers (ISPs), alternative DNS providers, Domain Name Registrars (DNRs), content delivery networks (CDNs), Hosting Service Providers (HSPs), e-commerce platforms, app aggregators, social media networks and payment intermediaries, and where necessary and proportionate for its effective implementation. The grant of a DBI should not, in itself, imply liability on the part of the intermediary for the underlying infringement. 11) DBI should remain in force only for so long as is necessary and proportionate in the circumstances and should be subject to review mechanisms. Review, Modification and Revocation of DBI 12) The grant or refusal of a DBI should be subject to a right of review or appeal, which will not necessarily have suspensive effect. Any person materially affected by a DBI should have an effective means of seeking the modification, revocation or termination of the DBI where appropriate.
Q300-RES-G-2026
5
13) National and regional legal frameworks may determine the grounds on which a DBI may be modified, revoked or terminated, upon request of the plaintiff, an infringer, an affected intermediary, or any other person materially affected by a DBI. Such grounds may include, where relevant:
• The DBI is no longer necessary, or circumstances justifying it have ceased to exist without a significant risk of recurrence;
• Circumstances justifying an amendment to the scope of the DBI; • Material misrepresentation, concealment, or bad faith by the plaintiff; • Abuse of the DBI resulting in restriction of lawful competition or non-
infringing services; • Failure to comply with the terms of the DBI, including
implementation/reporting requirements, if any; • Unintended chilling effects, disproportionate over-blocking of lawful content,
disproportionate interference with (i) legitimate business activities, (ii) freedom of expression or (iii) access to information.
Q297-RES-P-2026
1
2026 AIPPI World Congress – Hamburg Adopted Resolution 10 October 2026
Resolution
2026 – Study Question - Patents
Divisional applications and double patenting
Background: 1) AIPPI has studied divisional applications in Q193 "Divisional, Continuation and Continuation in Part Patent Applications" (Singapore 2007). This Resolution supplements Resolution Q193. 2) For the purposes of this resolution, a "Divisional Application" is any later patent application that claims subject matter disclosed in an earlier filed application (parent application) and is entitled to the same filing date as the parent application and the same priority date, if applicable. For the avoidance of doubt, if the later application contains any claims directed to subject matter not disclosed in the earlier application, those claims shall not be considered to fall within the scope of this Resolution. 3) This Resolution concerns double patenting in the context of Divisional Applications only and not double patenting in other contexts. This Resolution does not deal with questions of double patenting where patents are granted for the same jurisdiction by different patent granting authorities. 4) Divisional Applications are a key mechanism for applicants seeking to secure protection for multiple inventions disclosed in a single parent application. They allow applicants to pursue different subject matter while retaining the effective filing date of the original filing as the effective filing date of the Divisional Applications.
Q297-RES-P-2026
2
5) A central issue associated with Divisional Applications is double patenting. For the purposes of this resolution, “Double Patenting”, as its name suggests, refers to the granting of two or more independent patent rights for the same subject matter and having the same effective filing date, to the same applicant(s) in the same jurisdiction. For the purposes of this resolution, each “same applicant” refers to the applicant or to a successor in title of the applicant. Double Patenting may arise, e.g., when the claims of the parent and the divisional patent(s) are directed to the same subject matter, even if worded differently. 6) The substantive and procedural criteria used to assess Divisional Applications and Double Patenting vary significantly across jurisdictions. 7) Antitrust and competition law issues are outside the scope of this Resolution. 8) 44 Reports were received from AIPPI's National and Regional Groups and Independent Members, providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (which can be found at www.aippi.org). 9) At the AIPPI World Congress in Hamburg in 2026, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI. AIPPI resolves that: 1) There continues to be a need for harmonisation regarding Divisional Applications and Double Patenting in order to reduce the legal uncertainty arising from divergent national and regional approaches. 2) Double Patenting should not be permitted. An applicant should not be able to obtain more than one patent right in force for the same subject matter for the same jurisdiction by the same patent granting authority. An obviousness standard should not apply to determination of Double Patenting. 3) The assessment of Double Patenting with respect to a Divisional Application or a patent granted on the basis of that application should be based on patent rights
Q297-RES-P-2026
3
previously allowed or granted to the same applicant, or its successor in title, and which rights remain in force and have not lapsed, been invalidated, or revoked. 4) Where Double Patenting is found to exist, it should be resolvable by at least any of the following actions: abandoning or withdrawing one of the conflicting rights or amending the claims of one of the conflicting rights. 5) Double Patenting should not prevent simultaneous protection between different types of exclusivity rights. 6) In accordance with and supplementing Resolution Q193:
• The filing of Divisional Applications should be permitted based on either a parent application or any divisional family member at any time that such application is pending.
• Pending means that the prior application has not received a final ruling rejecting the application and has not issued as a granted patent. Pendency does not include any period when the prior patent is involved in post-grant proceedings.
• There should be no limit on the number of Divisional Applications that may be filed.
7) When a lack of unity objection is raised in respect of a patent application, the applicant should not be required to file all divisional applications at that time, and it should be possible to file a Divisional Application claiming more than one invention, without prejudice to the examiner's ability to issue a further lack of unity objection in respect of that Divisional Application. 8) Divisional Applications should be subject to the same examination process and patentability criteria as other patent applications. In particular, there should be no special limitation on the prosecution period of Divisional Applications, and no requirement to update the patent specification in view of the later filing date of the Divisional Application. Further, applicants should not be required to justify the need for filing a Divisional Application, nor to explain the relationship between the claims in the Divisional Application and the claims of the parent application. 9) Prosecution history of a parent application should not be binding on the prosecution of a Divisional Application derived from it, or vice versa.
Q297-RES-P-2026
4
10) The same criteria for assessing Double Patenting should also apply to Divisional Applications regardless of whether a Divisional Application was filed in response to a lack of unity objection or at the applicant's own discretion. Double patenting should not be applied by the same granting authority where the Divisional Application was filed in response to a lack of unity objection raised by the office and the applicant confined the Divisional Application to the subject matter to which that objection related. 11) The availability of divisional practice should not be restricted in order to address conduct by which a proprietor seeks to abuse a market position through the use of the patent system.
1
Q301-SC-RES-2026
2026 AIPPI World Congress – Hamburg Adopted Resolution 10 October 2026
Standing Committee on Biotech Resolution
Microbiome-Based Inventions
Background:
1) In recent years there has been a rapid increase in inventions, and correspondingly in patents and patent litigation, involving “microbiomes”, defined as “the collective of microorganisms that exist naturally in a particular environment, such as in the gut or the skin of a host organism”. Microbiome- based inventions also encompass isolated bacterial consortia, isolated individual bacterial strains, and/or genetically engineered bacterial strains. Microbiome-based inventions hold substantial promise for revolutionising approaches across a broad range of industries, including health, agriculture, fermentation technologies, production of “functional foods”, environmental sustainability, etc.
2) There is a lack of harmonisation between jurisdictions as to the requirements
for patent protection for microbiome-based inventions, and, in particular for subject matter eligibility and enablement requirements.
3)Article 27(1) of the Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights
Agreement (hereinafter “TRIPS”) indicates that patents shall be available for inventions, whether products or processes, in all fields of technology provided they are new, involve an inventive step, and are capable of an industrial application.
4) TRIPS Article 8(1) states:
2
"Members may, in formulating or amending their laws and regulations, adopt measures necessary to protect public health and nutrition, and to promote the public interest in sectors of vital importance to their socio- economic and technological development, provided that such measures are consistent with the provisions of this Agreement."
5) TRIPS Articles 27(2) allows – but does not require – members to exclude from
patentability: “…inventions, the prevention within their territory of the commercial exploitation of which is necessary to protect ordre public or morality, including to protect human, animal or plant life or health or to avoid serious prejudice to the environment, provided that such exclusion is not made merely because the exploitation is prohibited by their law.”
6) In Resolution Q93 (1994) on Biotechnology, AIPPI reaffirmed the broad principle that inventions involving living organisms (microorganisms, plants, animals, parts thereof, biological material, and processes to obtain or use them) should be patentable provided they meet the patentability criteria. The Resolution rejected narrowing “biotechnological inventions” to particular techniques and emphasized the beneficial role of patent protection for technological, economic and social progress. AIPPI also stated that moral and ethical issues arising from biotechnology should be dealt with by laws specifically addressing those concerns (and by existing patent exclusions for inventions contrary to ordre public or morality), rather than by introducing blanket prohibitions into patent law.
7) In Resolution Q259 (2017) on Gene Patenting AIPPI reaffirmed that, as a matter
of principle clearly reflected in TRIPS Agreement, patents should be granted for any inventions in all fields of technology including genes or parts thereof isolated from nature by a technical process or nucleic acid molecules artificially synthesized, provided an industrial, agricultural, diagnostic and/or therapeutic application is identified and other patentability criteria are met. Furthermore, genetic materials should not be regarded as subject matter excluded from patentability by virtue of TRIPS Articles 27(2) and (3) and should not be regarded as inventions contrary to ordre public or morality. AIPPI also resolved that genetic material “isolated” from nature by a technical process should not be
3
treated as a mere “product of nature” or found patent ineligible for that reason alone.
8) For microbiome-based inventions, uncertainty over requirements and lack of harmonisation pose significant challenges to the development of this important field, which may chill investment and hinder the potential of this technology to positively impact healthcare, nutrition, agriculture, and environmental sustainability.
9) AIPPI Standing Committee on Biotechnology initiated a study on microbiome-
based inventions. 31 Reports were received from AIPPI's National and Regional Groups and Independent Members providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Standing Committee on Biotechnology and by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (which can be found at www.aippi.org).
10) At the AIPPI World Congress in Hamburg in 2026, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI.
AIPPI resolves that: 1) There should be no categorical exclusion from patenting microbiome-based
inventions solely because they concern microorganisms, microbial consortia, or microbiomes isolated from natural environments; or biological material derived therefrom.
2) Patentability requirements for microbiome-based inventions should be assessed under ordinary principles applicable to biotechnology inventions (if applicable) rather than through technology-specific exclusions or prohibitive requirements.
4
3) Subject matter eligibility for microbiome-based inventions should not take into account other patentability requirements, including novelty, inventive step, enablement, or sufficiency.
4) Technical intervention should confer subject matter eligibility to microbiome- based inventions. Such technical intervention may include for example isolating, modifying, formulating, engineering, or using microorganisms, microbial consortia, or microbiomes originating from natural environments, or biological material derived therefrom.
5) Microbial consortia and other microbiome-based compositions should be assessed for patentability requirements as compositions of matter. This assessment should at least include consideration of formulation, functional interaction, and/or synergistic technical effect. Microbial consortia and microbiome-based compositions should not per se be ineligible for patent protection solely because their constituent organisms individually occur in nature.
6) Assessment of disclosure, enablement, sufficiency, and reproducibility of microbiome-based inventions should be internationally consistent and predictable. It should be possible to satisfy requirements with one or more of:
deposit of biological material, including microbial consortia; technical characterisation of microorganisms and/or microbial
consortia; genomic, proteomic, phenotypic, functional, and/or compositional data; validated analytical methods; the source or the process of obtaining the microbiome-based invention;
and other information enabling the skilled person to reproduce the invention.
7) Deposition of biological material under the Budapest Treaty and other systems
that accept deposits of biological material to support patent filings should be optional but, when a deposit is duly made and disclosed in the patent
5
application, the biological material should be considered to be sufficiently disclosed.
8) Depository Authorities under the Budapest Treaty and other systems that accept deposits of biological material to support patent filings should accept deposits of individual microorganisms, microbiomes and mixed microbial consortia to the extent technically possible.
1
Q298-RES-TM-2026
2026 AIPPI World Congress – Hamburg Adopted Resolution 10 October 2026
Resolution
2026 – Study Question - TM
Parody as a defence to trade mark infringement
Background: 1) This Study Question concerns parody and freedom of expression as a defence to trade mark infringement. 2) This Resolution intentionally does not define parody and may apply to related genres, such as satire, caricature and pastiche. 3) For purposes of this Resolution, the term “trade mark infringement” means any claims associated with the violation of a right based on a registered or unregistered trade mark, including trade mark dilution. 4) 45 Reports were received from AIPPI’s National and Regional Groups and Independent Members providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (which can be found at www.aippi.org). 5) At the AIPPI World Congress in Hamburg in 2026, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI.
2
AIPPI resolves that: 1) Under the conditions set out in this Resolution, in claims for trade mark infringement, there should be a defence based on parody and freedom of expression, jointly referred to as the “parody defence”. 2) The parody defence should be available if the parodic expression includes, but is not limited to, an element or elements of humor, art, criticism, mockery, debate, cultural creativity, social commentary, consumer or public interest discourse. 3) The parody defence should balance the rights and the legitimate interests of trade mark owners with the promotion and the protection of artistic freedom and freedom of expression. 4) The parody defence should be applied in a structured, limited, framework, rather than as a broad and unconditional parody exception to all trade mark claims. 5) The parody defence may be enacted by statute, or by judicial decision, also taking into account constitutional rights. 6) In claims for trade mark infringement, the parody defence should be available in relation to all types of trade marks, including well-known trade marks. 7) The parody defence should apply if the parodic expression is not used commercially, or in the course of trade, and is not used as a trade mark or an indication of origin save for the provision of paragraph 10. 8) Notwithstanding paragraph 7 above, the parody defence should not be precluded per se by commercial exploitation of a parodic expression, such as artists selling their parodic artistic creations for money, or parodic expression being published or broadcast in commercial media, save for the provision of paragraph 10. 9)Whether or not use of a parodic expression constitutes an infringement of a trade mark right must be assessed taking all relevant aspects of the situation into consideration, including but not limited to:
a) The parodic expression constitutes an expression of humour, criticism or mockery;
3
b) The parodic expression is noticeably different from the original trade mark or has a transformative aspect;
c) The parodic expression is used to sell goods or services that are non- competing and unrelated to those of the original trade mark;
d) The parodic expression is non-commercial and purely artistic; e) The parodic expression is non-commercial and used to draw attention to a
social message or otherwise to engage in consumer or public-interest discourse.
10) The use of a parodic expression should not be permitted to cause likelihood of confusion with the original trade mark or its owner, or take unfair advantage of, or be detrimental to the distinctive character or repute of the original trade mark. 11) Parody should be assessed objectively, and the intent of the creator shall not be decisive in determining whether the parody defence should apply to a claim of trade mark infringement. 12) There should be no special rule permitting or prohibiting the registration of parodic expressions as trade marks. Such applications for registration should be governed by the normal registration rules and procedures applicable to all marks, including but not limited to rules governing conflicts with prior marks.