Vastuskiri
| Dokumendiregister | Terviseamet |
| Viit | 6.3-9/24/1683-2 |
| Registreeritud | 22.02.2024 |
| Sünkroonitud | 27.03.2024 |
| Liik | Väljaminev dokument |
| Funktsioon | 6.3 Tervishoiutöötajate registreerimine ja kutsekvalifikatsiooni tunnustamine |
| Sari | 6.3-9 Kirjavahetus tervishoiutöötajate registreerimise ja kvalifikatsiooni küsimuses |
| Toimik | 6.3-9/2024 |
| Juurdepääsupiirang | Avalik |
| Juurdepääsupiirang | |
| Adressaat | Contact ENMCA |
| Saabumis/saatmisviis | Contact ENMCA |
| Vastutaja | Liina Saar (TA, Peadirektori asetäitja (3) vastutusvaldkond, Tervishoiuteenuste osakond) |
| Originaal | Ava uues aknas |
Failid
Dear Colleagues,
The Medical Council of Ireland is seeking to extend its knowledge of specialist training provided by universities / training bodies in Ukraine and we would be grateful if fellow regulators could share their experience with us.
I would be grateful if you would answer the following questions:
1. Have you accepted specialist qualifications obtained in Ukraine for the purpose of recognising a doctor as a specialised doctor?
Yes, we have processed the applications of Ukrainians, but since the study programmes in Ukraine are mostly too short term, the applicants get a refusal to be registered as specialist medical doctors. There have been exceptions in orthodontics (in which case they have to take the qualification’s exam in orthodontics as well).
2. If yes, can you advise in which specialties?
Anesthesiology, psychiatry, pediatrics, orthodontics so on.
Since the applicants know that they won’t get registered as specialist medical doctors they usually issue an application to get registered as a doctor without the speciality (basic medical training).
3. Could you provide details about your assessment process for these applications?
If the duration of the specialist medical training is shorter than in Estonia then the applicant will receive a refusal to be registered – this is about 99% of the cases.
If the applicant has already taken a qualification’s exam and gotten registered as a medical doctor + the duration of the specialist medical training equals or is longer than in Estonia + the applicant has worked as a specialist medical doctor for at least 3 years in a row during the 5 years before they issued the registration application (in case they acquired the specialist medical education for at least 5 years ago) then they will receive a decision referring them to take a qualification’s exam as a specialist doctor (practice period for about 4 months and a theory exam).
4. When assessing applications from Ukraine qualified specialists:
(i) have you found variations in the standard of specialist training across different universities /training bodies / regions in Ukraine?
If yes, could you comment on the differences?
N/A
(ii) have you found that the standard of specialist training in any university/ training bodies/ regions is more aligned to the standards set out in the Directive?
If yes, could you provide some information and indicate those universities / training bodies?
N/A
5. Any other comments.
N/A
Please send your responses to me at [email protected]
Many thanks for your assistance with my query.
Ann Curran
Registration Operations & Projects Lead
The Medical Council of Ireland is seeking to extend its knowledge of specialist training provided by universities / training bodies in Ukraine and we would be grateful if fellow regulators could share their experience with us.
I would be grateful if you would answer the following questions:
1. Have you accepted specialist qualifications obtained in Ukraine for the purpose of recognising a doctor as a specialised doctor?
Yes, we have processed the applications of Ukrainians, but since the study programmes in Ukraine are mostly too short term, the applicants get a refusal to be registered as specialist medical doctors. There have been exceptions in orthodontics (in which case they have to take the qualification’s exam in orthodontics as well).
2. If yes, can you advise in which specialties?
Anesthesiology, psychiatry, pediatrics, orthodontics so on.
Since the applicants know that they won’t get registered as specialist medical doctors they usually issue an application to get registered as a doctor without the speciality (basic medical training).
3. Could you provide details about your assessment process for these applications?
If the duration of the specialist medical training is shorter than in Estonia then the applicant will receive a refusal to be registered – this is about 99% of the cases.
If the applicant has already taken a qualification’s exam and gotten registered as a medical doctor + the duration of the specialist medical training equals or is longer than in Estonia + the applicant has worked as a specialist medical doctor for at least 3 years in a row during the 5 years before they issued the registration application (in case they acquired the specialist medical education for at least 5 years ago) then they will receive a decision referring them to take a qualification’s exam as a specialist doctor (practice period for about 4 months and a theory exam).
4. When assessing applications from Ukraine qualified specialists:
(i) have you found variations in the standard of specialist training across different universities /training bodies / regions in Ukraine?
If yes, could you comment on the differences?
N/A
(ii) have you found that the standard of specialist training in any university/ training bodies/ regions is more aligned to the standards set out in the Directive?
If yes, could you provide some information and indicate those universities / training bodies?
N/A
5. Any other comments.
N/A
Please send your responses to me at [email protected]
Many thanks for your assistance with my query.
Ann Curran
Registration Operations & Projects Lead
From: Liina Saar
Sent: Thu, 22 Feb 2024 13:43:19 +0000
To: '[email protected]' <[email protected]>
Subject: Vs: ENMCA survey - specialist qualifications from Ukraine
Hello
Please find the answers attached to this e-mail.
Liina Saar
Chief Specialist
Department of Health Care Services
+372 6509858
Republic of Estonia
Health Board
+372 794 3500
www.terviseamet.ee
Paldiski mnt 81, 10614 Tallinn
Estonia
This e-mail is confidential and meant for use by the person named in the letterhead. Any use in any way or copying of it by a person not marked as the addressee thereof is prohibited. If you have got this e-mail by mistake, please notify of it the sender without delay and delete the received e-mail together with all its attachments.
Saatja: Contact ENMCA <[email protected]>
Saatmisaeg: esmaspäev, 12. veebruar 2024 13:38
Adressaat: Contact ENMCA <[email protected]>
Teema: ENMCA survey - specialist qualifications from Ukraine
Tähelepanu! Tegemist on väljastpoolt asutust saabunud kirjaga. Tundmatu saatja korral palume linke ja faile mitte avada. |
Dear ENMCA participants
The Medical Council of Ireland would like to learn of your experiences in assessing applications for specialist registration from doctors who trained and qualified in Ukraine.
Please could you complete the attached survey and send your response to [email protected] by 29 February 2024.
Many thanks
Dear Colleagues,
The Medical Council of Ireland is seeking to extend its knowledge of specialist training provided by universities / training bodies in Ukraine and we would be grateful if fellow regulators could share their experience with us.
I would be grateful if you would answer the following questions:
1. Have you accepted specialist qualifications obtained in Ukraine for the purpose of recognising a doctor as a specialised doctor?
Yes, we have processed the applications of Ukrainians, but since the study programmes in Ukraine are mostly too short term, the applicants get a refusal to be registered as specialist medical doctors. There have been exceptions in orthodontics (in which case they have to take the qualification’s exam in orthodontics as well).
2. If yes, can you advise in which specialties?
Anesthesiology, psychiatry, pediatrics, orthodontics so on.
Since the applicants know that they won’t get registered as specialist medical doctors they usually issue an application to get registered as a doctor without the speciality (basic medical training).
3. Could you provide details about your assessment process for these applications?
If the duration of the specialist medical training is shorter than in Estonia then the applicant will receive a refusal to be registered – this is about 99% of the cases.
If the applicant has already taken a qualification’s exam and gotten registered as a medical doctor + the duration of the specialist medical training equals or is longer than in Estonia + the applicant has worked as a specialist medical doctor for at least 3 years in a row during the 5 years before they issued the registration application (in case they acquired the specialist medical education for at least 5 years ago) then they will receive a decision referring them to take a qualification’s exam as a specialist doctor (practice period for about 4 months and a theory exam).
4. When assessing applications from Ukraine qualified specialists:
(i) have you found variations in the standard of specialist training across different universities /training bodies / regions in Ukraine?
If yes, could you comment on the differences?
N/A
(ii) have you found that the standard of specialist training in any university/ training bodies/ regions is more aligned to the standards set out in the Directive?
If yes, could you provide some information and indicate those universities / training bodies?
N/A
5. Any other comments.
N/A
Please send your responses to me at [email protected]
Many thanks for your assistance with my query.
Ann Curran
Registration Operations & Projects Lead
The Medical Council of Ireland is seeking to extend its knowledge of specialist training provided by universities / training bodies in Ukraine and we would be grateful if fellow regulators could share their experience with us.
I would be grateful if you would answer the following questions:
1. Have you accepted specialist qualifications obtained in Ukraine for the purpose of recognising a doctor as a specialised doctor?
Yes, we have processed the applications of Ukrainians, but since the study programmes in Ukraine are mostly too short term, the applicants get a refusal to be registered as specialist medical doctors. There have been exceptions in orthodontics (in which case they have to take the qualification’s exam in orthodontics as well).
2. If yes, can you advise in which specialties?
Anesthesiology, psychiatry, pediatrics, orthodontics so on.
Since the applicants know that they won’t get registered as specialist medical doctors they usually issue an application to get registered as a doctor without the speciality (basic medical training).
3. Could you provide details about your assessment process for these applications?
If the duration of the specialist medical training is shorter than in Estonia then the applicant will receive a refusal to be registered – this is about 99% of the cases.
If the applicant has already taken a qualification’s exam and gotten registered as a medical doctor + the duration of the specialist medical training equals or is longer than in Estonia + the applicant has worked as a specialist medical doctor for at least 3 years in a row during the 5 years before they issued the registration application (in case they acquired the specialist medical education for at least 5 years ago) then they will receive a decision referring them to take a qualification’s exam as a specialist doctor (practice period for about 4 months and a theory exam).
4. When assessing applications from Ukraine qualified specialists:
(i) have you found variations in the standard of specialist training across different universities /training bodies / regions in Ukraine?
If yes, could you comment on the differences?
N/A
(ii) have you found that the standard of specialist training in any university/ training bodies/ regions is more aligned to the standards set out in the Directive?
If yes, could you provide some information and indicate those universities / training bodies?
N/A
5. Any other comments.
N/A
Please send your responses to me at [email protected]
Many thanks for your assistance with my query.
Ann Curran
Registration Operations & Projects Lead
Seosed
| Nimi | K.p. | Δ | Viit | Tüüp | Org | Osapooled |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kiri | 12.02.2024 | 44 | 6.3-9/24/1683-1 | Sissetulev dokument | ta | Contact ENMCA |